Movie Appraisal
After watching the documentary "Edward Said on Orientalism," it becomes evident that Edward Said's seminal work, "Orientalism," published in 1978, critically explores the pervasive stereotypes held by the West towards the East, encompassing various national perceptions. Said, as a critic, delves into the Western portrayal of the Middle East, highlighting the prevalent misrepresentations.
Initially, Said's involvement in Oriental studies was motivated by a critique of simplistic and often pejorative stereotypes of the East, particularly the American depiction of the Middle East as synonymous with terrorism. He contends that such perceptions grossly misrepresent the realities of those living in the Middle East. This bias is rooted in both governmental and media narratives that paint a monolithic image of the "Orient." This issue persists in contemporary media culture, where portrayals of the Middle East frequently resort to terrorist imagery in television, movies, and news outlets. Western media often correlates the region with war and poverty, focusing on political instability and religious extremism while seldom highlighting positive developments.
Furthermore, Said identifies historical and institutional underpinnings that sustain Orientalism's enduring misconceptions. The perpetuated false imagery of the Orient in Western consciousness has cemented a problematic view of Orientalism. This concept aligns with Boyd-Barrett's media imperialism, critiquing the power dynamics that manipulate cultural perceptions and oversimplify the representation of other cultures.
Media's role in reinforcing Orientalism is evident through stereotypical portrayals and oversimplifications. Reports of terrorist activities by Middle Eastern groups are frequently spotlighted, crafting a villainous image of the region. Disney movies and shows like "The Simpsons" contribute to embedding these stereotypes from an early age, portraying the Middle East as exotic, backward, and conflict-ridden. Orientalism's applicability extends to broader Asia, where China is often depicted as a solely traditional and ancient society, overshadowing its modernity and development. Similarly, Japan's portrayal tends to overlook its cultural diversity, further entrenching cultural misunderstandings.
Said poses a crucial question on how to embrace differences without resorting to violence and hostility. My perspective suggests beginning with education, fostering critical thinking from an early age to cultivate a multifaceted understanding of the world. Promoting study abroad and international exchange programs can enhance language skills and cultural appreciation. For adults, developing critical thinking and advocating for a pluralistic media landscape are vital.
In summary, the documentary underscores the ongoing challenge of media stereotypes. It is imperative to engage with media critically, questioning, and scrutinizing content for biases or stereotypes. Understanding the power dynamics behind media representations, supporting diverse narratives, and striving to learn about cultures through various lenses are essential steps toward dismantling Orientalist stereotypes and fostering a more inclusive worldview.
Comments